Romance Is In The Post

The Sunday edition of The Washington Post Book World was dedicated to Love and Heartbreak (their title, not mine). In addition to the regular love books - you know, the one about Castro and the other about Bin Laden - Book World reviewed a few actual romances. All except one had a Biggie author. Of the listings, the reviewer said:

Every Breath You Take by Judith McNaught - “The romance comes with a convoluted yet oddly compelling mystery as its backdrop, its power diminished somewhat by a surfeit of coincidences that would choke even Charles Dickens.” She lost me at “surfeit”…

All Night Long by Jayne Ann Krentz - “The plot is ridiculous but fun, while the prose, when you are able to notice, is flabby and slows down the action.” Never heard of “flabby” prose before, but okay.

The Instant When Everything Is Perfect by Jessica Barksdale Inclan - The storylines seem to include adultery and breast cancer. The review also says: “The air-brushed perfection of the main characters that is requisite for the genre is mitigated by the more realistic portrayal of bearing witness to a loved one’s battle with cancer.” No one told me I’m supposed to be writing about perfect people.

Heart Divided an anthology by Debbie Macomber, Katherine Stone and Lois Faye Dyer - “The characters tend to be two-dimensional, but the structure of the linked stories is clever.” That’s kind of positive.

Just Rewards by Barbara Taylor Bradford - I loved this part: “It’s the sort of novel where the women are apt to be named India, the men Gideon, and the houses Pennistone Royal.”

The only one I own is All Night Long. It’s probably the only one of these I’ll ever own or read.

4 Responses to “Romance Is In The Post”

  1. Sandy L Says:

    I read the Book World yesterday. I skimmed over the column you mentioned. I’m discovering that traditional romance is just not working for me right now. I want something different and out-of-the-box. However, reviews for these two books caught my eye: The Alchemist’s Daughter by Katharine McMahon and Eat, Pray, Love by Elizabeth Gilbert.

  2. Karen Scott Says:

    It’s the sort of novel where the women are apt to be named India, the men Gideon, and the houses Pennistone Royal.”

    Tee Hee Hee, the reviewer’s obviously read a few BBT’s before.

    I’m shocked that Danielle “Are Her Books Romance or not” Steele wasn’t on that list.

  3. trisha ashley Says:

    Well, the shortlist for the Romantic Novelist’s Association prize for Romantic Novel of the Year is out, here in the Uk, thought you might like to see it in comparison:

    Winds of Honour
    by Ashleigh Bingham
    Robert Hale

    An Eligible Bachelor
    by Veronica Henry
    Penguin

    As the Night Ends
    by Audrey Howard
    Hodder

    Gardens of Delight
    by Erica James
    Orion

    Recipes for a Perfect Marriage
    by Kate Kerrigan
    Pan Macmillan

    The Ship of Brides
    by Jojo Moyes
    Hodder

    True Believer
    by Nicholas Sparks
    Time Warner

    One or two surprises in there, especially Nicholas Sparks!

  4. HelenKay Says:

    Trisha - I only knew two of those. Yeah, Sparks was one of them. We won’t even have a discussion about him being on the list. Now I have to go check out the rest…

    Karen - I have some vague recollection of Book World reviewing Steele’s book last week or the week before. Uh-huh. That’s all I’m saying on that.

    Sandy - Saw both of those. My favorite part about the McMahon review was the reviewer - Diana Gabaldon. Book world listed her as a historical writer. Hmmmm.

Leave a Reply